← All insights
Leadership & Collaboration

When the role changes: What leadership has to do with identity

What changing roles mean for our sense of self – and how leaders, founders and investors can navigate changing responsibilities.

Sascha Adam and another person in conversation by reflective glass, overlooking a lake.

An experienced leader takes on broader responsibilities. A founder sees her idea grow into a company with its own layers of leadership. An entrepreneur steps back from day-to-day operations. A business angel supports people whose decisions he influences but does not make himself.

The situations are different. Yet over the years, I have encountered a similar question again and again – in others and in reflecting on my own development: How do I remain effective when the nature of my contribution changes?

Sometimes the question is openly discussed. More often, it shows up indirectly: in a decision someone is reluctant to hand over; in the surprise of being perceived differently by others; or in the feeling that a new role looks right on paper but does not yet quite feel like their own.

This is about more than skills. It is also about how we see ourselves: What defines me? What do others value me for? And what remains of that when my responsibilities change?

A new leadership role is more than a bigger version of the old one

One model that helps make this tangible is the Leadership Pipeline. In its 2024 edition, Ram Charan, Stephen Drotter, James L. Noel and Kent Jonasen describe several transitions: from individual professional work to leading others, then leading leaders, taking responsibility for a function, leading a business and finally leading an enterprise. [1]

The authors consider more than new skills. They also ask: How is time spent? And what does the person regard as important and valuable work?

That last point takes me beyond the model. When the way I create value changes, the way I and others recognise my effectiveness may change too.

The pipeline is a map, not a prescription for every career. In a growing company, a founder may occupy several roles at once. Others move sideways, temporarily take on additional responsibilities or consciously decide against the next hierarchical step. Even so, the model helps us look more closely at different kinds of change.

Five transitions – and five different questions

Leading others for the first time: Someone may previously have stood out through the quality of their own work, good ideas or the ability to solve difficult problems themselves. Now it becomes more important to help others succeed. That can be rewarding. But it can also raise the question of how to recognise one’s contribution when the visible result no longer comes directly from one’s own hands.

Leading leaders: Personal impact increasingly depends on how other people lead their teams. Someone who has drawn energy from direct contact and quickly helping others may need to find a new way of dealing with greater distance. Others see an opportunity in precisely this: they enjoy helping other leaders find their own way.

Leading a function: The role may include areas in which other people know more than the leader. Existing expertise remains valuable, but it will not be enough for every decision. A personal question may arise: How do I lead credibly when I am no longer the person with the deepest expertise in every area?

Leading a business: The task is to bring together perspectives from different functions. A former sales leader, product specialist or finance expert can still benefit from their background. At the same time, they must make decisions for the whole business – even when those decisions do not follow the most obvious logic of their original field.

Leading an enterprise or group: Responsibility changes again. Decisions reach across individual businesses and longer periods of time. Someone whose sense of effectiveness has been closely tied to operational work may wonder how to lead from a greater distance in a way that still feels personally right.

These are not five fixed psychological stages. They are questions that can arise from different roles. Not everyone experiences them this way, and a new responsibility does not necessarily bring doubt. But the differences matter: A change of role does not only change the scope of the work. It can also change what good work feels like.

What does this have to do with identity?

“Identity” can sound like a big word. In everyday work, I mean something quite concrete: the image we have of ourselves and the meaning we attach to what we do.

Perhaps I am the person who finds a solution under pressure. Perhaps I take pride in being there for my people. Perhaps I see myself as an independent creator, a dependable partner or someone who goes deep into the technical details before making a decision.

Such images do not develop in an afternoon. They grow from experience, achievements, feedback and the roles we have held over the years. They help us make decisions and recognise ourselves in our work. That is why a new role can be more than a practical adjustment when it touches these familiar points.

A research review of transitions into leadership roles distinguishes three perspectives: learning new tasks, developing one’s sense of oneself as a leader, and how that role is recognised in interaction with others. Its authors reviewed 136 publications. The abstract suggests, above all, that a role transition cannot be reduced to a list of competencies. [2]

This does not mean that someone’s entire personality is remade with every career move. A role can change while much of what makes a person who they are remains. But we may need to rediscover how those familiar parts find their place under different conditions.

Why the same change means different things to different people

Imagine three entrepreneurs who each hand over operational responsibility to others. These examples are fictional.

The first built his company because he loves working through technical problems. Trusting others is not necessarily difficult for him. He simply misses the part of his work in which he could delve deeply into a problem himself.

The second takes pride in her close connection to her team. She welcomes the new leadership layer but notices that personal conversations have become less frequent. For her, the issue is less about control than about closeness and belonging.

The third experiences the change mainly as a relief. He gains room to develop new business opportunities and finds that his role feels more aligned than before.

From the outside, the change looks similar. From the inside, it does not. Personality, experience and motives can influence what someone gains, misses or finds demanding. Yet no single trait reliably predicts how a person will respond to a particular leadership role.

Motivation research offers a useful, though more general, perspective. A 2026 meta-analysis found associations across many studies between experiences of autonomy, competence and relatedness and aspects of motivation and well-being at work. It did not specifically study transitions through the Leadership Pipeline. But it reminds us that work is more than a list of tasks – including for people in leadership roles. [3]

Perhaps it is the image of leadership that does not fit

Sometimes the tension is not between a person and their new responsibility, but between that person and the image they associate with “leadership”.

A study involving 35 professors illustrates this. All held a formal leadership role. Yet some primarily saw themselves as specialists, others as mentors, managers or shapers. Some who rejected the label “leader” nevertheless supported and developed their team members; they associated the word with an authoritarian image that did not fit them. The study was conducted in academia, and its groups are not universal leadership types. [4]

I find that distinction striking. Someone who has learned that a leader must always have the answer, appear decisive or maintain a certain distance may find a new role alien – even when other ways of leading would suit them much better.

That does not mean every personal preference is sufficient. Leadership also requires decisions, difficult conversations and responsibility for others. But it is worth examining what the role actually requires – and which expectations we add ourselves.

For founders, the company is often part of their own story

For founders, I believe another dimension comes into play. The company is not just a workplace or a leadership assignment. It may have grown from a personal idea, through individual decisions, and become closely connected to someone’s life over many years.

When other people begin to shape the business more strongly, that can feel both right and unfamiliar. The question is not simply whether someone can “let go”. It may also be about how their relationship changes with something that has long been an important part of their sense of self.

A three-year qualitative study of first-time founders describes how they remained strongly identified with their ventures while their perceived psychological closeness to them changed in different directions over time. It does not show that growth inevitably creates an identity conflict for founders. It does, however, help explain why the connection between a person and a company is more than a question of the organisational chart. [5]

Even an experienced entrepreneur may therefore reach a point where she asks herself anew: What does it mean to me to lead this business when I no longer do so in the same way as before?

What about investors and business angels?

Investors and business angels are not simply another level of the Leadership Pipeline. Their role follows a different logic: they carry financial responsibility, support decisions and often contribute experience and networks, while operational responsibility remains with the leadership teams of the companies involved.

That is precisely why I find the comparison interesting. Their role can change too: for example, when an operating entrepreneur becomes a supporter of other founders, or when one company requires something different from an earlier investment. A natural personal question might be: How do I contribute my experience without making other people’s decisions my own?

For someone who enjoys shaping things directly and acting quickly, this can mean finding a different form of effectiveness. For someone else, the opportunity to support development from some distance is particularly rewarding. This is an extension of my observation, not a claim from the Leadership Pipeline or a finding about all investors.

The roles are not the same. But they can touch on a shared question: What form of influence fits my responsibility – and how do I understand my own contribution within it?

A new role does not emerge in isolation

Even when someone becomes clearer about their own role, that is not the whole story. Other people also have an image of who that person is and what they expect from them.

A founder wants decisions to be made more firmly within the leadership team, but people still come directly to her whenever they are uncertain. A former colleague takes on a leadership role and finds that others still primarily see him as their technical contact. A new managing director tries to distribute responsibility differently while the actual decision rights remain unclear.

It would be too simple to attribute all of this tension to personality. People develop their roles in interaction with others – and under the conditions that actually exist. Sometimes the issue is not willingness but a lack of clear authority, experience in the team, time to learn or an open conversation about expectations.

This also applies to new technology. If AI changes tasks in which a leader previously invested considerable time or demonstrated expertise, it may raise questions about their contribution. Whether it does, and to what extent, depends on the work and the person. Technology alone does not tell the whole story.

What helps when a role does not quite fit yet?

A new role does not develop simply because someone resolves to make it work. But it can help to look more closely – without turning every moment of discomfort into a crisis.

1. Name the change specifically

What is actually different from before? Which decisions now lie with me, and which no longer do? Where does my contribution happen today? And what do others explicitly expect – rather than what I imagine they expect?

2. Take the personal meaning seriously

What might I miss about the previous role? Technical depth? Direct contact? Independence? The immediate feeling of completing something? Conversely, what does the change make possible that was previously neglected?

3. Distinguish what to preserve from what to change

Not everything that mattered before has to disappear. The question is how it can find a place in the new role. Technical curiosity, for example, may show up in asking better questions. The pleasure of developing people may shift from leading a team directly to supporting other leaders.

4. Experiment and seek feedback

A new understanding of leadership does not arise through reflection alone. It can also be tested in daily work: in a decision, a conversation or collaboration with other leaders. Feedback from people willing to say honestly how they experience one’s behaviour can help.

For example, let the team prepare a decision that has previously been yours. First clarify who will make the decision, then discuss together what worked well.

A qualitative study of 22 experienced leaders describes how many, looking back, developed a more personal understanding of their leadership role through observation, experimentation, feedback and reflection. Two participants did not describe a comparable development. The study points to possible paths, not a guaranteed outcome. [6]

5. Examine the conditions too

Not every tension can be resolved through personal development. Conflicting goals, responsibility without decision-making authority, or important skills that still need to be built within the team also belong in the conversation. And sometimes a role is simply not the right one – that too can be a legitimate conclusion.

Not having to become someone else

The longer I think about this topic, the more important this distinction seems to me: A new role may require us to act differently. It does not automatically require us to become an entirely different person.

A leader can learn to solve fewer problems personally without losing their technical curiosity. An entrepreneur can let others make more decisions without losing her connection to the company. An investor can contribute experience without taking over the founding team’s responsibilities.

What helps will differ from person to person. In my view, it begins with an honest question: What needs to change in my new role – and which part of that touches something that matters to me personally?

Perhaps that is where a different understanding of leadership development begins: not as an instruction to fit a template, but as a conscious effort to bring responsibility and one’s sense of self into alignment.

The role can change. The question is how we can fulfil it in a way that fits both the responsibility and the person taking it on.

Sources and context

The starting point is The Leadership Pipeline: Developing Leaders in the Digital Age by Ram Charan, Stephen Drotter, James L. Noel and Kent Jonasen, third edition, 2024. The article also draws on the linked research on leadership identity, motivation and entrepreneurship. This is not a complete account of those sources; the connection with my observations and its application to different roles are my editorial interpretation and an invitation to discussion.

Note on how this article was created

This article was created with the support of AI. I make that visible for the sake of transparency and see no contradiction between that and personal authorship.

For me, the decisive question is not whether a first draft is produced with the help of a tool. It is who sets the direction, sharpens the ideas, guides the iterations, checks the wording and ultimately stands behind the content.

This text is therefore the result of briefings, iterations, professional interpretation and my own revision. In the end, I publish only what reflects my views and what I am personally prepared to stand behind.